Campus Dispatch- Volume 6

The Title VI edition

Vol 6, Title VI edition

Welcome to Campus Dispatch, an FSJP newsletter. Keeping you informed on what’s really happening at Portland State! 

This volume is dedicated to the PSU Title VI investigation. Read FSJP’s statement with details that counter what PSU and Ann Cudd are telling news outlets.

PSU Title VI Investigation

From: Portland State University Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine 

On August 15, 2024, President Ann Cudd and Portland State University were notified that the U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights (OCR) was opening an investigation on the failure to respond to the harassment of Palestinian and Muslim students and faculty in a manner consistent with the requirements of Title

VI. Specifically, OCR is investigating the failure of PSU to respond appropriately to reports of anti-Palestinian and Islamophobic flyers posted in a campus building. 

As noted in the Oregonian (August 8) and Vanguard (September 20), over the summer, faculty, students, and staff found and removed anti-Palestinian flyers on the first floor of Cramer Hall. 

To be clear, students, faculty, and staff found and removed anti-Palestinian flyers at least 3 times a week in the same exact location of Cramer Hall. At least 5 different reports were made to President Cudd and the PSU administration about the flyers. 

On August 8, faculty and staff identified and spoke with the person responsible for posting the flyers. The name of the individual was shared with the PSU administration and the OCR investigating attorney…

We are withholding the name of the individual responsible because we want to remain focused on holding President Cudd responsible for allowing ongoing harassment of Palestinian and Muslim students and faculty. 

Despite claims otherwise, there was no response from PSU during the months of July and August concerning the flyers. In fact, a PSU administrator minimized the anti-Palestinian sentiment by stating PSU was “aware of flyers posted in Cramer Hall that some may consider hate speech” in the August 8th Oregonian article. 

On September 3rd, the PSU administration sent a response about the flyers to only a few people on campus. President Cudd briefly mentioned the Oregonian article and PSU response in her September 13th blog post. In her blog post, the President omits that the flyers were continuously removed by faculty, students, and staff rather than by facilities or PSU administration. The President also omits that the reports made by students, faculty, and staff to President Cudd and PSU Office of Equity and Compliance were responded to inconsistently at best and intentionally misleading at worst. Nor did she report that PSU was under an OCR Title VI investigation for failing to respond appropriately. 

In that same blog post, President Cudd again centered the safety of Jewish students while she allowed the spread of anti-Palestinian hate in Cramer Hall. This creates a dangerous and inflammatory rhetoric that deepens divides, promotes intolerance, and is capable of inciting widespread discrimination and violence beyond the PSU campus. 

We are deeply troubled by the silence around the flyers and the connection of the responsible individual to a large PSU donor. We are troubled by the ways PSU donors, Board of Trustee members, and others are influencing President Cudd’s inconsistent and opaque response to anti-Palestinian hate on campus. 

We urge the PSU community to be vigilant in holding President Cudd to a standard of transparency and inclusion for all on campus. We ask for transparency around the formation and the rights and responsibilities of the Committee on Socially Responsible Investment and Partnership. We ask the committee to look beyond connections to Boeing in examining the local, national, and global impacts of PSU donors and other partnerships.

PSU Title VI News Coverage

The Oregonian: “Feds investigate PSU in connection with Islamophobic flyers posted on campus,” October 24, 2024

Federal authorities are investigating Portland State University in connection with Islamophobic flyers that appeared on campus last summer and that some faculty and students said didn’t draw a swift enough reaction from administrators…” (Read full article here) 

Sean Meagher/The Oregonian

KOIN: “DOE’s Civil Rights office investigates anti-Palestinian flyers at Portland State,” Oct 24, 2024

Protesters calling for a ceasefire in Gaza set up camp on the campus of Portland State University. April 30, 2024 (KOIN)

“University spokesperson Katy Swordfisk said the flyers were taken down “promptly.” According to a newsletter Portland State University Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine published on Wednesday, the flyers were removed by students, staff and faculty, rather than administration…” (Read full article here)

CAIR: “CAIR Welcomes Federal Probe of Racist, Anti-Palestinian Flyers at Portland State U.,” Oct 23, 2024

“We welcome this federal investigation of the promotion of racist anti-Palestinian hate on campus and hope it sends the message that those who oppose the far-right Israeli government’s genocide in Gaza have the right to free speech without facing harassment or intimidation,” said CAIR Research & Advocacy Coordinator Farah Afify…(Read full article here) 

OPB: “Portland State University faces federal investigation for possible civil rights violation,” Oct 23, 2024

A small group of Portland State University students, alums and supporters march around the block, near the PSU Administration building, Oct. 7, 2024.

“There were instances where fliers were posted more than once per day so people were taking them down and [the fliers] were going back up,” said Stéphanie Wahab, a Portland State professor in the School of Social Work. “The posters were incredibly racist towards Palestinians.” Wahab, who is a member of PSU Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine, said the university took too long to address the situation and alert the wider campus community. Wahab said it was individual students and faculty who took down most of the offensive posters.… (Read full article here)

KGW8: “Federal investigation launched into Portland State over racist flyers circulating on campus,” Oct 22, 2024

“The group Portland State University Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine sent KGW a statement that said at least five different reports about the flyers were made to PSU administration, and nothing was done.” (Read full article here) 

One has only two options in such cases: resist or strengthen the unjust institution. Thus in cases of oppression by choice, failing to resist harms others.

Ann Cudd, Analyzing Oppression, p.200

PSUFA Blog: PSU President Ann Cudd Gives a Revealing Interview on OPB’s Think Out Loud,” October 28, 2024

Pres. Cudd in a recent candid interview with the PSU Vanguard

“When asked by host Dave Miller how larger class sizes caused by cutting instructional faculty would affect students’ learning experience, Cudd insisted students would be better off in larger classes of upwards of 30 students. She explained her reasoning as follows:

Because nobody likes to be in a class that has only about four or five other students, because if you don’t show up you really are noticed, for one thing. But the other thing is that it’s all on you and a couple of others to carry on the discussion and actually, you know, work together. So it’s a better classroom experience when there are more students than that...” (read full article here)

Truthout: Chalking Bans and ID Checks at Protests Repress Palestine Solidarity on Campus,” October 13, 2024

“Alongside outright bans on encampments at virtually every university come a coordinated set of campus policies, including mask bans, mandatory ID policies, bans on chalking, new protest guidelines and even curricula and syllabi review, all of which promise to severely undermine academic freedom and free speech. On some campuses, as in the California State University system, these restrictions are enacted through “Time, Place, and Manner” policies…”(read full article here)

Attendees gather for a vigil organized by the Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Maryland on October 07, 2024 in College Park, Maryland.

PSU Vanguard: “Dueling Library Narratives: How Corporate Media Distorts Campus Protests,” October 21, 2024

Graffiti etched onto the walls inside the occupied library condemns Israel and calls for action. Courtesy of an anonymous source

While many off-campus and corporate media sites are happy to toe the line of the University Administration and Portland Police Bureau (PPB), on-campus coverage actually dug into the nuts and bolts of the library’s reopening. PSU Vanguard’s coverage included an Instagram post, which included a more detailed cost breakdown of the repairs and a very important quote missing from nearly every other news source in the city. ...” (read full article here)

Watson Institute for International and Public Affairs: “The Human Toll: Indirect Deaths from War in Gaza and the West Bank, October 7, 2023 Forward,” October 21, 2024

“This report covers the human costs of the Hamas strike and Israel’s military operations since October 7, 2023 in Gaza and the West Bank. Costs of War is a research project focused on U.S. military spending, as well as direct and indirect deaths associated with U.S. wars and militarism. In just one year, as a companion report shows, the U.S. has spent at least $22.76 billion on military aid to Israel and related U.S. operations in the region.…”(read full paper here)

The Language of Palestinian Embroidery with Wafa Ghnaim

Nov 1, 2024 6:00pm

The First Unitarian Church of Portland

1211 SW Main

Wafa Ghnaim is a Palestinian dress historian, researcher, author, archivist, curator, embroiderer, and educator who began learning embroidery from her mother, award-winning artist Feryal Abbasi-Ghnaim, when she was two years old.

Al Wadi Dance Company & Studio Datura present Palestine Cinema Days

Screening: Naila and the Uprising: An Inspiring Global Film Event,

Saturday Nov 2, 1:30pm

Datura Studio, 116 NE Russell St. Portland Or.

Admission: Free

Palestinian Children’s Days of Action Nov 7-10

In response to Palestinian poet Mosab Abu Toha’s call for children’s actions, kids of all ages, families, educators, and community members will mobilize November 7-10, 2024. Take action in solidarity with Palestinian kids who’ve held their own marches and press conferences to resist the Zionist state’s genocide against the Palestinian people.

Feedback? Questions? Have a tip for us? Contact us at: [email protected]